Hello, Buffalo Chicken Big Mac!

Let’s make Chicken Big Mac copycats at home!

Jump to Recipe


Read Time: 6 minutes

Some big fast-food sandwich news broke last week. McDonald’s is bringing their Chicken-based version of the Big Mac to the United States. This sandwich has been a hit in the United Kingdom and the folks in the corporate office decided to bless some other countries with it.

You might not know it, but there are a lot of journalists out there getting paid to write about fast-food sandwiches.

The Chicken Big Mac has been fairly large news in the fast-food, junk food news world and I’ve skimmed a few articles about it. I’m sure it will do well for McDonald’s since they have fancy computer machines dialed into the sales of the sandwich in the UK.

I’ve always thought the Big Mac (like many club sandwiches) has a lopsided bread-to-meat ratio and I feel this particular chicken sandwich would be better with the middle roll removed and a larger chicken patty included instead of two skinny ones. I tweeted about the coming Chicken Big Mac and got a few good replies about how other folks might make it more interesting.

But enough thinking; let’s make our own Chicken Big Mac. But maybe we’ll also take a shot at making a more interesting version.

What is a Chicken Big Mac?

At this point, I’m assuming everyone knows what a Big Mac is. I wrote about a plant-based copycat of the Big Mac last year when I covered Impossible vs Beyond burger meat. You can check that out if you’d like a closer look at how to make a Big Mac at home (it’s easy to substitute regular ground beef for the plant-based “meat” versions I used).

The Chicken Big Mac is exactly the same as a regular Big Mac but the all-beef patties have been replaced with what McDonald’s calls “tempura fried chicken patties”. These are probably McChicken patties, which are simply listed as “boneless chicken” on the official McD’s allergen information. These are made from ground chicken meat, much like a very large McNugget and then they are breaded and fried. Because they are ground meat, you can shape them similar to the size of your bun for consistency and that’s what I ended up doing.

The Chicken Big Mac is coming to the United States, but only to Miami, Florida at first. So if you want to try it, you either have to buy a plane ticket or you can use my recipes below to make your own.

I made this piece of marketing material for McDonald’s in photoshop. Someone on their team took the food photo, I stole it off Google image search and then added the jingle text. I am sending them an invoice for my efforts. 💵💰

What are we making?

Well, first I made a regular homemade Chicken Big Mac just to see if it was any good. And it is! There’s still too much bread though. But since the entire United Kingdom seems to love the Chicken Big Mac, I carried on.

Here’s my attempt at a Chicken Big Mac. Just like the regular beef Big Mac, it appears they’re still putting a slice of American cheese on the very bottom as a lunatic would do.
My fried chicken patties are a tiny bit too thick, which makes everything taller, but I believe mine is going to be better than the restaurant version.

Here’s my regular Chicken Big Mac recipe:

1 hour and 45 minutes
Chicken Big Mac copycat

Want to make your own copycat version of a Chicken Big Mac at home? Here's the recipe I use to make it happen.

Get Recipe

And keep reading to find out how to make this in a much more exciting Buffalo Chicken Big Mac version.

The Buffalo Chicken Big Mac copycat

Here is my version of promotional materials for the Buffalo Chicken Big Mac. The jingle isn’t quite as smooth as the original, but I’ll still be singing it in the shower. Please email me if you’re a commercial jingle writer to help me clean things up here.

Two all-chicken patties

As I wrote above, these are basically just glorified, large, fried chicken nuggets. I wrote about chicken nugget sliders in the past and these patties are similar but not quite the same.

I used chicken breast meat, and I ran the meat through the grinder attachment for my food processor. I ground the meat once, seasoned it with salt, garlic powder, and onion powder, mixed everything up, and then ground the meat again. Using a 4-inch round biscuit cutter, I shaped several patties and then moved them to the freezer to solidify.

If you’re grinding meat with a meat grinder attachment or a food processor it works best if you freeze the metal components for at least half an hour before use.
I used a 4-inch biscuit cutter as a mold to form consistently round, ground chicken patties.

There’s no binder in these chicken patties, so you’re using the freezing tactic to keep all the meat in the proper shape and form during frying.

It’s also easy to forget that your patties will grow after being dredged in egg, buttermilk, and flour and then fried. So, if you think your patty is too thin, it likely will not be too thin after it’s fully cooked.

Making sure your patties are consistent is a big deal in this style of sandwich. Make sure the patties fit your buns as well.
These were thin-ish patties, but they were still thicker than you’d get at McDonald’s.

Buffalo sauce

Buffalo sauce is awesome in its simplicity unless you plan to make your own hot sauce. If you are cool with using store-bought hot sauce, an easy buffalo sauce can be two ingredients: butter and hot sauce. I and a whole lot of the rest of the world, typically use Frank’s RedHot brand, but you can do it with any brand of hot sauce.

Lettuce 🥬

*Here are some words to fill up the lettuce section*

Please add more lettuce-related content in the comments below if you have any. It was iceberg lettuce, shaved off the head and sliced thin. That’s it.

Blue cheese

Buffalo sauce requires blue cheese. Some folks prefer ranch, and they are incorrect.

I made a thicker blue cheese dressing to accompany this Buffalo Chicken Big Mac and stand in as a sandwich sauce. In my recipe, I do explain that you should use buttermilk or regular milk to control the viscosity of your dressing/sauce. That’s the last ingredient you add and if you want a dressing for a salad, you might want to add more liquid to create a thinner dressing, but if you want a blue cheese spread, you will add less liquid so that the sauce doesn’t just run off of the sandwich.

10 minutes
Blue cheese dressing

Thick and tangy with flavors from the sharp and flavorful blue cheese sets us up in a place where this will be great for sandwiches or salads. Add more buttermilk (or milk) to thin it out if you want it pourable.

Get Recipe

Pickled celery

I pickled some celery for this sandwich. I figured we could either replace the pickles from the original big mac with celery or have celery AND pickles which seems weird, or we could just pickle the damn celery and so that’s what I did.

Because I wanted these to be both similar to dill pickles and also retain their celery characteristics I used my MSG dill pickle recipe and did not cook or boil the celery. This way it retains some of its crunch, while still being very pickled and dilly.

My wife and I were excited about the flavors and texture of pickled celery, and we might just have gotten inspired for another application for it in the sandwich world.

This celery turned out great and it worked fantastic in the sandwich (SPOILER).
Recipe Card
25 minutes
Pickled celery

It turns out that one of the worst vegetables in the world can be redeemed greatly with a bit of pickling. These are great with buffalo wings and even better if you keep them in stalks and put them in your bloody mary!

Get Recipe

On a sesame seed bun

Here are some of my potato rolls that have been painted with egg wash and coated in sesame seeds prior to baking.

These were my potato burger buns that I forced to be a bit taller and a few grams heavier. Normally I flatten my buns (*context*) and force them to rise in a less round shape that works better for sandwiching, but in this case, I left them very spherical to have more area for the middle “club” bun slice.

Note: in McDonald’s lingo, the three bun pieces for a Big Mac are called the heel (bottom), club (middle), and crown (top).

If the bun is tall enough, you can make two slices to cut out the club (middle) slice. If you have normal store-bought buns, you probably will have to sacrifice a second bun, slice the top and bottom off, or slice a tiny sliver off a bottom bun to get this club piece. If you have to slice up an extra bun to get that club piece, don’t throw the extra parts of the bun in the trash. Put them in a container or freezer zip-top bag and freeze the pieces to create breadcrumbs or make croutons in the future. Bread freezes fantastically.

Here are the crown, club, and heel bun pieces I used. I did toast them. Toasted in this sandwich is definitely better.

Here’s the updated version of my potato bun recipe. The difference here is that I painted on an egg wash and sprinkled each bun with sesame seeds before baking.

To be a bit more accurate, I probably should have used an egg white wash instead of a whole egg wash here. A whole egg wash (including the yolk) will make your final baked buns shiny, whereas an egg white wash will not. McDonald’s buns are not shiny under the sesame seeds, so they are not rolling with the yolks.

2 hours and 45 minutes
Super soft potato buns v2

Here's our updated bun recipe that's perfect for your next burger night. Try this updated version that uses potato flour and dry milk for a lighter bun.

Get Recipe

Buffalo Chicken Big Mac recipe

Here’s my entire recipe for the buffalo chicken Big Mac.

Buffalo chicken Big Mac copycat view printable page for this recipe

Spicy and creamy version of a Chicken Big Mac. If you like buffalo wings, you'll dig this version.


Ingredients:

Chicken patties
  • 1 pound ground chicken meat (thigh or breast or a combination of the two)
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • 1 teaspoon granulated sugar
  • 12 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 12 teaspoon onion powder
Chicken patty dredge and frying
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1 tablespoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon ground black pepper
  • 1 teaspoon paprika
  • 1 whole egg
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • peanut oil or another neutral frying oil (enough to fill at least 2 inches in your pot or pan)
Sandwich assembly
  • 3 tablespoons butter
  • 12 cup hot sauce (I use Frank's RedHot)
  • 4 soft burger buns (the top and bottom of 2 buns will be sacrificed)
  • 8 to 10 tablespoons blue cheese dressing/sauce
  • pickles or pickled celery or raw celery (sliced in small pieces)
  • lettuce, shredded
  • 4 chicken patties (from above)

Directions:

Fried chicken patties: grind your own chicken in a food processor or meat grinder. You can also purchase ground chicken from the store if you can find it. If you've never processed ground chicken before and you own a food processor, chop the meat into small 1/2-inch pieces and add to a food processor, pulse until you have a paste of ground chicken with no large pieces.

Grab a small bowl and pour 1/2 to 1 cup of water into it. You will be using this to dip your hands/fingers in while you're shaping chicken patties and the water helps your hands to not stick to the chicken as much.

In a large bowl add chicken, sugar, salt, garlic powder, and onion powder. Wet your hands and use them to mix up all the chicken and spices. Your hands are the best tool for this, and you will have to use them again in shaping your patties. 

Line a sheet pan with parchment and spray with non-stick baking spray if you want. This will help the patties not stick to the surface as much, but it's optional. Take a quarter of a portion of the chicken mixture and spoon it onto the parchment. With wet hands, shape the chicken mixture into a round shape that is similar to the size of the bun that you have. Do this 3 more times until you run out of the chicken mixture. I found that you'd want your raw chicken patties to be about a quarter to a half-inch thick. 

Once your patties are formed, they need to go into the freezer to firm up. You can freeze them for an hour and then if you want, you can remove them from the sheet pan and package them up in freezer-safe bags and store them in the freezer until you plan to use them. I wouldn't store them for more than a few months, but up to a couple of weeks in the freezer should be just fine. 

Chicken patty dredging and frying: When you are ready to make your sandwiches, it's time to make the dredging station.

Grab two large dishes. In one dish add your all-purpose flour, salt, ground black pepper, and paprika. Stir it all up. In the second bowl, add your whole egg and buttermilk and whisk to combine. 

Remove your frozen chicken patties and one at a time coat them in flour, then dip them in the egg/buttermilk mixture and then back into the flour. You want to make sure they are coated thoroughly after each step. In the end, they should be coated in a thin amount of seasoned flour. Place each flour-coated patty on a plate, cutting board, or cooling rack to wait for frying. 

Add at least 2 inches of oil to a large pot and add to medium-high heat on your stove. If you have an instant-read thermometer or frying thermometer, you want to get the oil temperature up to 350 F (176 C). 

Fry each patty for 5 to 6 minutes or until they are golden brown. I suggest flipping each patty at about the 3-minute mark and cooking for the rest of the time on the second side. 

Rest your fried patties on a cooling rack or a paper towel-lined sheet pan while you cook the rest.

Buffalo sauce: add butter to a medium skillet or pot over medium heat. 

When the butter has melted, add hot sauce and stir to combine.

Cook a couple more minutes and then remove from the heat.

Add chicken patties to the pan with the sauce and flip a couple of times to get a good coating of sauce on each patty.

Sandwich assembly: prepare your buns by slicing two buns normally and then cutting the very top and the very bottom off two other buns. You just need the middle parts of these last two buns. The top and bottom can be frozen and used later for breadcrumbs or turned into croutons.

Toast all six bun slices. 

To the bottom, toasted slice of the bun, add 2 tablespoons of blue cheese dressing and a small pile of lettuce. 

Top the lettuce with one of your buffalo sauce-coated chicken patties and then top that patty with the middle slice of bun. 

On the middle slice of the bun, you will add another 2 tablespoons of blue cheese dressing, more lettuce, and a few pickles or pickled celery. 

Top that with a second buffalo sauce-coated chicken patty and then crown with the top bun. 

Serve your Buffalo Chicken Big Macs and enjoy.

Did you order a Buffalo Chicken Big Mac? Well, I’ll relay your frustration to your Door Dash driver when I see them!
Just a beautiful guy over here eating a beautiful, responsibly sized sandwich.
The Buffalo Chicken Big Mac in all its glory.

This was a good sandwich

You should make one of these at home! If I made them again, I would get rid of that middle, club, piece of bun though. My wife enjoyed a similar version of this sandwich but with just one fried chicken patty and no club piece of bun and hers looked like a way more balanced sandwich experience.

Reminder: no sandwich post next Monday because of the US Labor Day holiday but check back next Tuesday when I actually fulfill what I promised last week and get into the pork and greens!


Enjoyed reading? Subscribe and I'll email you the next time I post a new sandwich.

Advertisement

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.