These aren’t Carmela Soprano’s meatballs covered in Sunday gravy, these are Thanksgiving-style turkey and cranberry stuffing meatballs swimming in turkey gravy and melty provolone.

Read Time: 9 minutes

Let’s dive into a tasty and messy, gravy-ladled sandwich that I think is perfect for this time of year. This sub sandwich has turkey, seasonings that are popular in Thanksgiving stuffing, cranberries in a couple of different ways, and a turkey gravy that you’ll think your Grandma might have made.

What is this sandwich?

This comforting sandwich has savory gravy as well as sweet and tart cranberries in two different components.

As you can see from the photo above, I’m writing about a meatball sub, but it’s not a traditional Italian-American-style meatball sandwich with marinara and melty mozzarella cheese. You won’t find this version featured in any episode of The Sopranos. This is a very non-traditional meatball sandwich, but it’s perfect for the Thanksgiving and Holiday season. If you’ve been following along, you’ll likely know that this isn’t the first meatball sub I’ve written about. It’s the fourth!

Other meatball subs

Difference between an asteroid and a meatball? – a very tasty sriracha-glazed meatball sub.
Meatball subs for Sandwich Artists – this is the traditional meatball sub that you’ve likely enjoyed before.
A meatball for your thoughts – Thai-inspired green curry meatball sub using ground pork and pickled bahn mi-style veggies.

But really, what is this sandwich?

This is a turkey meatball sandwich that uses ground turkey, store-bought cornbread stuffing mix, dried cranberries, and seasonings that you might find on your Thanksgiving table. When the meatballs are mostly cooked in a skillet, they’re removed and replaced by butter, flour, and chicken (or turkey) broth to create a gravy that reduces while the meatballs cook to temperature.

The meatballs are going in a herby onion sandwich roll with a cranberry and chipotle mayonnaise, provolone cheese, and those crispy fried onions that you’ll typically find topping your aunt’s green bean casserole. This is a sandwich that leans heavily into November and December, and eating one feels like a warm, gravy-filled hug.

Now that we know what sandwich we’re making, let’s get into the bread.

Herby onion sub rolls

For this fall-focused sub sandwich, I decided to change up my regular sub roll recipe and introduce some herbiness and onion flavor. To achieve this, I have used Italian seasoning, parsley flakes, and a packet of dried onion soup mix.

The onion soup mix is an important ingredient in my mom’s Thanksgiving dressing recipe, so I do think about this and usually have a packet in the pantry during this time of year. I’ve never actually made soup with it, though…

The herbs and dried onion flavorings are mixed, and most of it is added into the sub roll dough recipe, reserving a couple of tablespoons to sprinkle on top of the rolls prior to baking. Other than that, it’s just a simple roll recipe that requires an hour or so for initial dough proofing, then shaping into long torpedoes and another fermentation and rise time.

I wrote a whole blog post about sub sandwich rolls that you can check out if you’re interested. It’s also got a pretty good turkey sandwich recipe wrapped in after I cover all the details and steps for making nice, soft American-style sub rolls.

As I said, you save some of the herby onion mix to top the proofed rolls with a bit more seasoning, but I also add extra dried onion flakes just to seal the deal and give the rolls extra flavor and aroma.

After a bake time of a bit over 25 minutes, the rolls should be nicely browned with an interesting exterior surface.

These rolls are soft, as you would expect from a simple sub roll, but they have the added benefit of a bunch of oniony flavor. If you didn’t want to make these rolls, you could easily find a sub roll or French roll at your local stores.

Below is my recipe if you’d like to give it a shot. Just be aware that your kitchen will be adrift with onion and herby aromas for a bit.

3 hours
Herby onion sub rolls

These onion-focused rolls will introduce a big pop of herbaceousness to your next sub sandwich. Lipton brand onion soup packets are the ones I see most often, but you can use any dried onion soup packets to make these fun and flavorful bread rolls.

Get Recipe

Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatballs and turkey gravy

These are seasonally focused meatballs made from ground turkey. The panade of the meatballs, or the breadcrumbs + liquid portion that keeps things moist, is made from a store-bought stuffing mix, and dried cranberries are added, which brings a great sweet and tart flavor to what is typically a very savory experience.

My wife and I use Pepperidge Farm’s cornbread classic stuffing to make my mom’s Thanksgiving dressing recipe, but you can use pretty much any breadcrumb-based stuffing mix in this recipe. The version that I buy does have some seasonings already included, so if you can’t find this brand, just take that into account.

The salt level is pretty low in these mixes, but they do have seasonings that will be incorporated into your meatballs. The wet part of the panade is going to come almost entirely from two whisked eggs and a tiny bit of Worcestershire sauce.

Dried cranberries, sometimes called craisins, are loosely chopped to make them a tiny bit smaller before being added directly into the meatball mixture. I dug into a 10-year-old “Rescuing Turkey Meatballs” blog post and recipe from America’s Test Kitchen before refining my recipe. The above-linked blog post and associated recipe are written and tested by Andrew Janjigian, otherwise known on social media and his website as Wordloaf. I’ve covered Janjigian’s recipes a time or two on this blog, and I definitely used some of his ideas from that turkey meatball blog post for this recipe.

Breaducation:
If you’re reading this on the day I posted, Andrew Janjigian’s new book called Breaducation will be released tomorrow. I have not seen the book yet, but I have heard good things. Preorder or pick it up at your local bookstore.

Making the meatballs is super easy once you have all of your ingredients. Basically, you just get your hands dirty and mix everything in a large bowl. Once everything is fully combined, I like to use a 1/3 or 1/4 cup sized measuring scoop to portion out fairly equal balls. Just note that the 1/3 cup size will be pretty large meatballs. After each meatball is portioned and rolled into a ball, place it on a parchment-lined sheet pan or plate and stash it in the fridge for at least 15 minutes to help firm up the meat and give the gelatin some time to set up.

Once it’s time to cook, heat up some oil in a large pan and cook the meatballs for about 7 minutes, turning every few minutes. This process is simply meant to get a little sear on the outside of the meatballs. It will not cook them all the way through. Remove the meatballs to a paper towel-lined plate while you get the gravy started.

Now to work on the gravy

Gravy is mostly a simple science situation of combining fat with a thickener and then adding liquid. We accomplish that in this recipe with butter, all-purpose flour, and chicken stock (or turkey stock). Here’s my stand-alone gravy recipe that you can use if you want to see the simple concept, but the procedure for this meatball and gravy recipe will be very similar.

15 minutes
Turkey gravy

Gravy is a science, but not difficult science like college science. It's easy science, like middle school science. In most cases, gravy is an equal amount of fat and flour and then you add the liquid.

Get Recipe

First, we remove the meatballs to a paper-towel-lined plate, but do not wipe out the pan. Add butter and cook until it’s all melted and bubbly. If it starts to brown quickly, turn off the heat and sprinkle in the flour. Stir aggressively until all of the flour is coated in fat and cook for 1 minute or so.

If you turned off the heat, turn it back on to medium-low and add the chicken broth. Bring the pan to a simmer, stir things really well, and then add the meatballs back into the pan. Keeping the heat under the pan fairly low, cover the pan and simmer for 15 minutes with the lid on top.

After about 15 minutes, you should have some fully cooked and tender meatballs and a gravy that might appear a little bit thin, but it will thicken upon standing. I enjoyed these meatballs with gravy a couple of times on a bed of mashed potatoes, so I added it as a stand-alone recipe, but the full meatball and gravy process is outlined in the full sandwich recipe below as well.

40 minutes
Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatballs with turkey gravy

Looking for some super tasty and savory turkey meatballs with a touch of tart cranberry sweetness? These meatballs and the associated turkey gravy will provide a comforting and tender experience to be enjoyed spooned atop mashed potatoes or rice.

Get Recipe

Cranberry and chipotle mayonnaise

If you take nothing else from this sandwich blog post, you should bookmark this easy, mayonnaise upgrade recipe. It requires no cooking and just three ingredients to create a slightly sweet spread that has a bit of smokiness, which works great on a deli-style sandwich or, obviously, a turkey meatball sub.

Basically, I suggest that in the days leading up to Thanksgiving, buy a can of chipotles, and then you can use store-bought cranberry sauce or homemade to create this spread that works perfectly with turkey on a Day-after-Thanksgiving melt or even just a leftover roll and a couple of slices of turkey or ham. Keep this one in your back pocket for turkey day.

A meatball sandwich doesn’t really require mayonnaise in my opinion, especially one with gravy on it, but the addition of smoky chipotles and tart cranberries brings a depth of flavor that just works. Here’s my recipe for the sauce, but it’s also included in the full sandwich recipe below.

5 minutes
Cranberry chipotle mayonnaise

A little bit sweet, a little bit smoky and a lot bit savory spread for your next sandwich. Works great on a turkey or chicken sandwich, or practically any cold cut option. This is also a great dip for french fries or potato chips.

Get Recipe

Crispy fried onions

If you’ve been reading along with my sandwich writing for a while, you already know that I’m a big fan of store-bought crispy onions. Because of some magic drying and crisping techniques that happen in the industrial factories where they are made, these have a crispiness that you can’t really replicate in your home kitchen.

I do have a crispy fried onion strings recipe, and a crispy fried shallot recipe that would both work great in this sandwich if you wanted to spend a bit more time and effort instead of using store-bought. Since it’s the Thanksgiving season, you might already have some of the French’s version in your pantry, and it’s much easier and likely crispier to just use those.

Cheese

I don’t think this meatball sub requires cheese, but I used some anyway. I didn’t want the cheese to steal any focus from the cranberry stuffing meatballs or the turkey gravy, so I went with a neutral provolone. I could see Swiss or even cheddar working just fine, though, so feel free to experiment with your options if you want.

I did not intentionally melt the cheese under a broiler or anything. The cheese just softened and melted because the meatballs and the gravy that I spooned on top of it were so warm. If you wanted to toast the roll a bit, that would allow you to melt the cheese even more. But in my experience, the hot turkey gravy was enough to handle making the cheese all gooey.

Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatball sub sandwich recipe and photos

I ate a bunch of turkey meatballs while writing this blog post. Scroll through and see what I made, and just past the photos you’ll find the full recipe.

Let me know if you decide to celebrate Thanksgiving with turkey and cranberry meatballs instead of a whole bird. It’s a pretty good sandwich, which probably isn’t surprising since it has a few spoonfuls of gravy on it.

Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatball sandwich view printable page for this recipe

This turkey meatball sandwich is a tasty and messy, gravy-ladled sandwich that I think is perfect for the fall season. It's savory with just a hint of sweetness that complements the flavors of Thanksgiving.


Ingredients:

Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatballs
  • 2 pounds ground turkey (93% fat)
  • 2 large eggs, beaten
  • 3⁄4 cup Parmesan cheese, grated
  • 1⁄2 cup dried cranberries (crasins), roughly chopped
  • 1 1⁄4 cup cornbread stuffing mix (or other dried stuffing mix)
  • 1 tablespoon poultry seasoning
  • 1 tablespoon Worchestershire sauce
  • 1 1⁄2 teaspoon powdered gelatin
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1⁄2 teaspoon ground black pepper
  • 1⁄4 teaspoon MSG (optional)
Meatball cooking process and turkey gravy
  • 3 tablespoons vegetable oil or olive oil
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 4 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 3 cups turkey or chicken stock
  • 1 tablespoon Better Than Bouillon roasted chicken base (optional)
Cranberry chipotle mayo and Sandwich assembly
  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1⁄4 cup cranberry sauce
  • 2 teaspoons finely diced chipotle (in sauce)
  • 2 teaspoons adobo sauce (from the can of chipotle)
  • six-inch sub sandwich roll
  • 2 to 3 cooked meatballs (from above)
  • 1 to 2 slices provolone cheese (or Swiss/Cheddar)
  • turkey gravy (from above)
  • store-bought crispy fried onions

Directions:

Turkey and cranberry stuffing meatballs: In a large bowl, combine all of the turkey and cranberry stuffing meatball ingredients. Using your hands, mix everything together until the seasonings and breadcrumbs are fully incorporated into the meat.

Form the meat into consistent-sized balls. If you have a 1/4 or 1/3 measuring cup, you can use that to ensure that the meatballs will be about the same size. A 1/3 cup or scoop will make pretty large meatballs.

Once you've formed all of your meatball mixture into balls, place them on a sheet pan or plate and place them in the refrigerator for about 15 minutes. 

Meatball cooking: After 15 minutes, place a large pan over medium-high heat. Add 3 tablespoons oil to the pan.

Once the oil is shimmering, add meatballs and cook them for around 7 minutes, turning each meatball every 2 minutes or so to try to get some color on the exterior. After 7 minutes, remove the meatballs to a plate. They will not be fully cooked, just seared on the exterior. Do not wipe out the pan.

Turkey gravy: Turn the heat under the pan down to low. Add 4 tablespoons of butter, and once the butter is melted, sprinkle over 4 tablespoons of all-purpose flour. Stir until there are no dry, floury spots and the butter is fully melted and mixed in with the flour to form a light brown paste.

Add 3 cups chicken or turkey broth and stir until everything is combined. Raise the heat under the pan to medium-low and bring the mixture to a simmer. 

Add 1 tablespoon of Better Than Bouillon (if using) and stir. Return meatballs to the pan and simmer everything with the cover on the pan for 15 minutes. 

After 15 minutes, remove the cover and check to see if the gravy has thickened. It will thicken a bit as it cools, but if it's still very runny, you can simmer for another 2 or 3 minutes to thicken it up. 

Cranberry chipotle mayonnaise: combine mayonnaise, cranberry sauce, chopped chipotles, and some adobo sauce in a small bowl. Whisk to combine. This is your cranberry chipotle mayo.

Sandwich assembly: slice a sub roll so you can open it up like a book and spread some cranberry chipotle mayo on the bottom. Place 2 to 3 meatballs inside the roll.

Place the slices of cheese on top of the meatballs and then spoon on hot gravy to help melt the cheese. 

Sprinkle on crispy fried onions. For the best experience, wrap the sandwich in aluminum foil or parchment paper for a bit to help warm everything through and melt the cheese. 

Check back in 2 weeks

I have no clue what sandwich I’ll be making and covering, but we can find out together. If you think you’ll forget to check back, you should subscribe, and I’ll email you when I figure things out.