Add the flour, salt, sugar, and yeast into a large bowl and mix to combine. Then add the yogurt, butter, and warm water into the flour mixture.
Mix everything thoroughly with a spoon until there's no dry flour in the bowl. This dough should be pretty wet and shaggy.
You will want to knead with your hands at this point, but you should add as little extra flour as possible. I suggest oiling your fingers and possibly adding a little extra oil to the bottom of the bowl before kneading, which should help a little with the sticking problems. Knead as much as you can, about 2 or 3 minutes.
Get the dough into roughly a ball shape and let it rest in the bowl (covered) in a warm spot in your kitchen for one hour.
After one hour, flour a flat surface and dump out your proofed dough. At this point, you will want to divide the dough into 4 pieces. If you have a scale, you can make sure they're consistently sized.
Roll each portioned dough piece out into balls.
Place a large skillet or griddle over medium-low heat.
While the pan is preheating, start shaping each dough ball one at a time into a disk. You will need to sprinkle flour on the dough and the flat counter if the dough is really sticky. Press or roll (with a rolling pin) the dough into flatter and wider disks. Flatbread will puff up, but it will not puff out, so the diameter of the disk you have pre-cooked is what you will end up with after cooking.
Once you have a somewhat circular flat piece of dough, transfer it carefully to the hot skillet or griddle. Cook for 2 minutes on the first side and flip. Continue cooking for around 2 minutes on each side until you start seeing brown spots on the dough. The flatbread may puff up during this process, and that is a good thing. Press it down with a spatula to keep it consistently cooking.
Once your flatbread is spotted on the outside and puffy, add it to a plate or pan covered with a clean towel. The towel allows the flatbreads to steam themselves a little, which makes them even more pliable.
Continue this process for all of your dough balls until they are all turned into naan.
Serve and enjoy.
Notes:
If you'd like to spread melted butter on top of your naan, swap out the clean kitchen towel for aluminum foil instead. Wrap the finished, buttered naan in foil to help them steam just a bit more as they finish cooking.